Metal vs. Asphalt: Which is Better for Roofing Shingles?

Residential asphalt roof shingles

It can be confusing to choose between asphalt and metal, especially when you start to plan for roof replacement or installation, but knowing some guidelines should make it easier aside from knowing your budget limitations.

Homeowners have different options for metal roofing, unlike asphalt shingles. Some choose metal since they want a stronger and energy-efficient material for their home, others choose asphalt for a more affordable installation or replacement. Asphalt shingles can be installed without the help of a professional, which is ideal for DIY projects, making it a cheaper option than metal roofing. If you need to add seamless rain gutters, however, Utah homeowners are advised to hire a professional since it can be a complicated project.

Comparing Asphalt And Metal

Asphalt is ideal for those who want a visually appealing roof, although your options are limited if your budget can only afford standard materials. Contractors normally use typical colors, shades, and textures for low-budget installations, and using special materials will definitely require you to spend more.

This will not be a problem when you choose metal. The higher cost makes up for the wide range of choices in color, format, and metal, but take note that using a unique or custom style will be more expensive. On average, installing a 1,500-square-foot metal roof will cost at least $4,500, including the cost of labor. An asphalt roof of the same size may cost at least $3,000 on average, inclusive of labor fees.

Additional Cost Factors

Piggy bank, paper house, and coinsUrban residents should expect to spend more than those who live in suburban and rural areas. Prices of materials and labor in the city are often more expensive because of the higher demand. Other factors that affect the overall price include the height and pitch of the roof. Complicated structures and hard-to-reach areas also determine the exact price.

Aim to spend more than the average price, whether you plan to install an asphalt or metal roof. As metal roofing lasts longer, you could be saving more money over the long term by not having to replace it frequently. If asphalt is only your choice, invest in architectural shingles that could last for up to 25 years. Remember that asphalt roofs only last for up to 20 years, while metal roofing lasts for up to 70 years.

Sustainable Features

Metal has more sustainable features than asphalt, and this should be the case because the former is more expensive. Metal roofing can help with cooling your house during summer and insulation during winter, which reduces your electric bill from using the HVAC unit.

Asphalt roofs can insulate your house as well, but this can be a problem during the summer months. You will have to consult a roofing expert on how to avoid this from becoming an inconvenience.

Metal is the better choice when it comes to energy efficiency and lifespan, while asphalt is more suitable for budget-conscious homeowners. Whichever you choose, a professional installation would be more capable of maximizing the distinct benefits of each type.

The Author

Scroll to Top